.svg)
If you're a fan of true crime and want to share your passion with other enthusiasts, starting your own true crime podcast is a great way to do that. With the right tools, a bit of creativity, and some dedication, you can create a podcast that both educates and entertains your listeners. From coming up with an original topic to executing a successful episode, this guide will provide you with all the information you need to start your own true crime podcast.
True crime podcasts have exploded in popularity, captivating audiences with their gripping narratives and investigative journalism. These audio experiences offer listeners a chance to explore real-life mysteries, understand criminal psychology, and even contribute to solving cold cases. Starting your own true crime podcast can be both creatively fulfilling and potentially profitable if you approach it with the right strategy and respect for the subject matter.
True crime podcasts have captured the imagination of millions of listeners worldwide, creating a dedicated community of fans who eagerly await new episodes. The genre's popularity stems from our innate curiosity about the darker aspects of human behavior and our desire to understand the "why" behind criminal acts.
Our fascination with true crime stories runs deeper than simple morbid curiosity. Many listeners find these podcasts intellectually stimulating as they engage with complex psychological and social factors that contribute to criminal behavior. The format allows for deep dives into cases, examining evidence and testimonies that might have been overlooked in traditional media coverage.
True crime podcasts also provide a safe way to explore dangerous situations from a distance. Listeners can learn about potential warning signs and safety measures while processing their fears in a controlled environment. This educational aspect helps many justify their interest in what might otherwise seem like a macabre fascination.
The storytelling element cannot be overlooked either. Well-crafted true crime podcasts combine journalistic integrity with narrative techniques that keep listeners engaged episode after episode. The serialized format creates suspense and encourages audience participation through theories and discussions.
True crime podcasts have demonstrated remarkable potential for bringing attention to unsolved cases and even contributing to justice. Shows like "Serial" and "Up and Vanished" have led to reopened investigations and new evidence coming to light.
These podcasts provide a platform for victims' families to share their stories and keep public interest alive in cases that might otherwise fade from memory. The collective power of an engaged audience can generate new leads and pressure authorities to revisit evidence with fresh perspectives.
By highlighting flaws in investigations or judicial proceedings, true crime podcasts also contribute to important conversations about criminal justice reform. They expose systemic issues and biases that might otherwise remain hidden from public view, potentially leading to meaningful changes in how cases are handled.
Creating a successful true crime podcast requires careful planning and preparation before you ever hit the record button. Taking time to develop your concept and format will set you up for long-term success and help you stand out in an increasingly crowded field.
The true crime podcast landscape has become increasingly competitive, making it essential to find your unique perspective. Consider what specific aspects of true crime interest you most and how you can bring something new to the conversation.
You might focus on a particular type of crime, geographic region, or historical period that hasn't been extensively covered. Perhaps you have professional expertise in law enforcement, psychology, or forensics that provides you with special insight. Your personal connection to a location or type of case could also give your podcast authenticity that listeners will appreciate.
Remember that the most successful true crime podcasts balance entertainment with respect for victims and their families. Sensationalizing tragedies for shock value not only raises ethical concerns but can alienate thoughtful listeners who seek substantive content. Instead, focus on thorough research and thoughtful analysis that adds meaningful context to the cases you cover.
The format you choose for your true crime podcast will significantly impact your production process and audience experience. Consider these popular approaches:
Your choice of format should align with your strengths as a creator and the types of stories you want to tell. Narrative formats require strong writing and editing skills, while conversational shows depend on host chemistry and the ability to maintain engaging dialogue.
Consider your production capabilities as well. Highly produced formats demand more time and technical expertise, while conversational shows can be simpler to record and edit. Be realistic about the time you can commit to research, recording, and post-production when choosing your approach.
Thorough research forms the foundation of any credible true crime podcast. Cutting corners here will undermine your credibility and potentially spread misinformation about sensitive cases. Develop a systematic approach to gathering information from multiple sources.
Start with publicly available court documents, police reports, and news coverage to establish the basic facts of a case. These primary sources provide the most reliable information and help you avoid perpetuating myths or inaccuracies that may have spread through secondary reporting.
Interviews with those connected to cases can provide valuable perspectives, but approach this aspect with sensitivity and ethics in mind. Always be transparent about your intentions and respect boundaries when contacting victims' families, witnesses, or experts. Remember that these individuals have lived through traumatic experiences that you're exploring as content.
Create a consistent system for organizing your research materials by case, including timelines, key players, evidence, and unanswered questions. This organization will prove invaluable during script writing and recording, helping you present information clearly and accurately.
While content remains king, audio quality significantly impacts listener retention. Poor sound can make even the most fascinating stories difficult to follow. Fortunately, you can achieve professional-sounding results without breaking the bank by investing in the right foundational equipment.
The microphone serves as the cornerstone of your podcast setup, directly influencing how your voice translates to listeners' ears. For true crime podcasting, clarity is particularly important as you'll often be discussing complex details that listeners need to follow easily.
Consider these microphone options based on your budget and needs:
If choosing XLR microphones, you'll also need an audio interface—a device that connects your microphone to your computer and converts analog signals to digital. Popular options include the Focusrite Scarlett series or the Rode RODECaster Pro, which combines an interface with additional podcast-specific features.
When selecting equipment, consider your recording environment and format. Will you be recording with co-hosts or guests in the same room? Do you plan to conduct field interviews? These factors will influence whether you need multiple microphones and what type will serve you best.
Once you have your microphone setup, you'll need software to capture and edit your recordings. The right software can streamline your workflow and help you achieve professional-sounding results even as a beginner.
For recording, consider these popular options:
When choosing recording software, consider your technical comfort level and how much time you're willing to invest in learning new tools. Starting with simpler software and upgrading as your skills develop is often the most practical approach.
Remember that consistent audio quality across episodes helps build listener trust and comfort. Once you've established your recording setup, create a checklist of settings and procedures to follow for each session to maintain that consistency.
With your technical setup in place, the focus shifts to creating content that will captivate your audience and keep them coming back episode after episode. True crime podcasting requires a delicate balance between entertainment and respect for the serious nature of the subject matter.
Whether you follow a fully scripted format or work from detailed outlines, thoughtful preparation ensures your episodes flow logically and maintain audience interest. Good scripts provide structure while allowing your authentic voice to shine through.
Begin each episode with a compelling hook that immediately draws listeners in. This might be a provocative question, a striking detail from the case, or a broader theme that connects to the story you're about to tell. The first 30 seconds are crucial for capturing attention in today's crowded podcast landscape.
Structure your narrative with a clear beginning, middle, and end, even when discussing complex cases with many twists and turns. Guide listeners through the timeline of events while highlighting key turning points and unanswered questions. Consider using techniques like foreshadowing to maintain suspense and keep listeners engaged throughout longer episodes.
Pay special attention to transitions between segments or topics. These moments often determine whether listeners stay engaged or become confused and tune out. Clear signposting helps your audience follow along, especially when presenting detailed information about investigations or court proceedings.
Including interviews with relevant guests can add depth and credibility to your podcast. These conversations provide expert insights and different perspectives that enrich your coverage of cases.
When seeking potential guests, consider reaching out to:
Prepare thoroughly for each interview by researching your guest's background and expertise. Develop a list of questions that play to their specific knowledge while advancing your episode's narrative. While having a structure is important, remain flexible enough to follow interesting tangents that may emerge during the conversation.
During interviews, practice active listening rather than simply waiting for your turn to ask the next question. Thoughtful follow-up questions based on what your guest has just shared often yield the most insightful responses. Remember that your role is to facilitate their expertise for your audience's benefit.
True crime podcasting comes with significant ethical responsibilities. You're discussing real tragedies that have profoundly affected real people. Maintaining sensitivity while creating engaging content requires ongoing reflection and clear guidelines.
Establish your ethical boundaries before you begin producing episodes. Consider how you'll approach potentially sensationalistic details, whether you'll include graphic content warnings, and how you'll discuss victims and their families. Having these principles in place helps you make consistent decisions when difficult questions arise.
Focus on the human elements of cases rather than exploiting tragedy for shock value. Humanize victims by sharing details about their lives beyond their victimization. Similarly, avoid demonizing or glorifying perpetrators, instead examining the complex factors that may have contributed to their actions.
Be transparent with your audience about your research process and the limitations of available information. Clearly distinguish between established facts and speculation or theories. This honesty builds trust with listeners and demonstrates respect for the serious nature of the cases you're discussing.
The editing process transforms your raw recordings into polished episodes that meet professional standards. While this stage can be time-consuming, especially for beginners, it's where your podcast truly comes together and where you can elevate the listening experience.
Good editing makes your podcast sound natural and professional while removing distractions that might pull listeners out of the story. Learning basic editing techniques will significantly improve your show's quality.
Start by removing obvious mistakes, long pauses, and filler words (um, uh, like) that disrupt the flow of your narration. However, be careful not to over-edit to the point where your speech sounds unnatural. Some hesitations and variations in pace are part of normal conversation and can make your delivery more authentic.
Pay attention to volume consistency throughout your episode. Listeners shouldn't need to adjust their volume between segments or when switching between narration and interview clips. Use normalization and compression tools in your editing software to achieve consistent levels.
Background noise can be particularly distracting in true crime podcasts where listeners need to focus on detailed information. Apply noise reduction techniques to minimize air conditioning hums, computer fans, or other ambient sounds that might have been captured during recording.
Strategic use of music and sound effects can dramatically enhance the atmosphere of your true crime podcast, helping to set the tone and emphasize key moments. However, restraint is important to avoid creating something that feels overly produced or disrespectful.
When selecting background music:
Sound effects can be effective when used sparingly to illustrate specific elements of a case, such as emergency sirens or environmental sounds relevant to a location being discussed. However, dramatic sound effects that sensationalize violent aspects of cases are generally considered in poor taste within the genre.
Create standard templates for your intro, outro, and segment transitions to maintain consistency across episodes. These familiar audio elements help listeners orient themselves within your content and contribute to your podcast's brand identity.
Before publishing, take time to optimize your audio files for distribution across podcast platforms. This technical preparation ensures listeners have a smooth experience regardless of how they access your show.
Export your final episodes as MP3 files with appropriate settings for spoken-word content. A bit rate of 96-128 kbps mono typically provides excellent voice clarity while keeping file sizes manageable for listeners with limited data plans or storage space.
Include appropriate metadata with each episode file, including consistent titles, episode numbers, and descriptive information. This metadata helps podcast platforms properly categorize and display your content, making it easier for potential listeners to find.
Consider the length of your episodes based on your content and audience. While some true crime podcasts successfully produce multi-hour episodes, others find that 30-45 minutes is the sweet spot for their storytelling approach. Be guided by what serves your content best rather than arbitrary guidelines.
Creating great content is only half the battle—you also need to help potential listeners discover your podcast in an increasingly crowded marketplace. Building an audience requires consistent effort across multiple channels and a strategic approach to promotion.
Getting your podcast listed on all major platforms is essential for reaching the widest possible audience. Most listeners have preferred apps for podcast consumption, so availability across platforms removes barriers to discovery.
Follow these steps to distribute your podcast effectively:
Remember that each platform has specific technical requirements and submission processes. Take time to understand these details to ensure smooth distribution and avoid delays in having your show approved and listed.
Social media provides powerful tools for connecting with potential listeners and building community around your podcast. Different platforms offer unique advantages for podcast promotion, so consider which align best with your target audience.
Instagram works well for sharing visually engaging content related to your episodes, such as case timelines, evidence photos (when appropriate), or behind-the-scenes glimpses of your recording process. Stories and Reels can capture attention with short-form content that directs users to full episodes.
Twitter enables real-time engagement with true crime communities and conversations about breaking news related to cases you've covered. The platform's text-focused nature makes it ideal for sharing interesting facts, quotes from episodes, or links to new releases.
Facebook Groups can help you build dedicated communities where listeners discuss episodes, share theories, and connect with you directly. These groups foster deeper engagement than passive content consumption and can create loyal fans who help promote your show to others.
Regardless of which platforms you choose, consistency is key. Develop a content calendar that includes regular posts about new episodes, relevant news, and engagement opportunities. Respond promptly to comments and messages to build relationships with your audience.
Engaged listeners become your most powerful marketing tool as they share episodes, leave reviews, and recommend your show to friends. Actively cultivating this engagement can accelerate your podcast's growth.
Encourage listeners to participate in your podcast through:
Acknowledge listener contributions in your episodes by reading comments, answering questions, or discussing theories they've submitted. This recognition creates a sense of community and demonstrates that you value their participation.
Reviews significantly impact podcast discovery, as many platforms use them in ranking algorithms and potential listeners often check them before subscribing. Regularly ask your audience to leave honest reviews, explaining how this simple action helps support the show's growth.
While passion for the genre might be your primary motivation, developing revenue streams can help sustain your podcast long-term and potentially turn it into a viable business. Several monetization options exist, from traditional advertising to direct listener support.
Podcast advertising has become a billion-dollar industry, with true crime shows often commanding premium rates due to their engaged audiences. As your listenership grows, sponsorships can provide substantial revenue.
The most common advertising formats include:
Host-read ads typically perform best, as they leverage the trust you've built with your audience. When selecting sponsors, consider whether their products or services align with your show's values and would genuinely interest your listeners. Maintaining authenticity in ad reads helps preserve audience trust.
You can secure advertising through podcast networks, advertising marketplaces like Podcorn or AdvertiseCast, or by directly contacting brands that might be interested in reaching your audience. As your show grows, consider working with a dedicated podcast advertising agency that can negotiate better rates on your behalf.
Subscription models offer a way to generate revenue directly from your most dedicated listeners while providing them with additional value. This approach can provide more stable income than advertising alone.
Consider offering premium content such as:
Platforms like Patreon, Apple Podcasts Subscriptions, or Spotify's Anchor provide the infrastructure to offer tiered membership levels with different benefits. Start with affordable entry points to make subscription accessible while offering higher tiers for those willing to provide more support.
When designing your premium content strategy, ensure that your free podcast remains valuable and complete in itself. Premium content should enhance the listener experience rather than make them feel they're missing essential information if they don't pay.
Physical products and experiences offer additional revenue streams while strengthening connections with your audience. These tangible extensions of your podcast brand can appeal to your most enthusiastic fans.
Popular merchandise options for true crime podcasts include:
Live events can range from virtual Q&A sessions to in-person live recordings or true crime conventions. These events not only generate revenue through ticket sales but also create memorable experiences that deepen audience loyalty.
When developing merchandise, focus on quality and relevance rather than simply slapping your logo on generic products. The best podcast merchandise reflects the specific interests and inside references that resonate with your community of listeners.
True crime podcasting involves discussing sensitive topics with real-world implications. Understanding the legal boundaries and ethical responsibilities is essential for creating content that respects all parties involved while protecting yourself from potential liability.
Legal considerations should inform how you research, write, and present your podcast content. While you don't need to be a legal expert, familiarizing yourself with basic principles helps you avoid common pitfalls.
Fair use allows limited use of copyrighted material without permission for purposes such as commentary, criticism, or news reporting. However, the boundaries are not always clear-cut. When using news clips, court recordings, or other copyrighted content, consider:
Defamation involves making false statements that harm someone's reputation. When discussing suspects who haven't been convicted or presenting theories about cases, be careful to distinguish between established facts and speculation. Using qualifying language like "allegedly" or "according to court documents" can help protect you from defamation claims.
Consider consulting with a media attorney to review your format and approach before launching your podcast. Some podcasters also obtain media liability insurance to provide additional protection against potential legal challenges.
Ethical true crime podcasting places respect for victims and their families at its core. This respect should guide every aspect of how you research, write, and present your content.
Before covering a case, consider whether the victims' families have expressed wishes about media coverage. Some families actively seek attention for unsolved cases, while others prefer privacy. When possible, reach out to families through appropriate channels to understand their perspective.
Be mindful of how you discuss victims, focusing on their lives rather than just the circumstances of their deaths. Avoid sensationalizing details of crimes or using victims' suffering primarily for entertainment value. Consider whether including certain graphic details serves a legitimate purpose in understanding the case.
Give thought to the timing of your coverage, particularly for recent cases where wounds remain fresh. The passage of time can provide important context and allow for more thoughtful analysis than immediate coverage of breaking cases.
While podcasting may feel more informal than traditional journalism, maintaining high standards for accuracy and fairness builds credibility with your audience and shows respect for your subject matter.
Verify information through multiple sources whenever possible, especially for controversial or contested aspects of cases. Clearly communicate your research process to listeners so they understand the foundation of your reporting.
Present multiple perspectives on complex cases rather than advancing a single narrative. This balanced approach acknowledges the nuances that often exist in true crime stories and allows listeners to form their own informed opinions.
When you make mistakes—as all content creators eventually will—correct them promptly and transparently. Acknowledge errors in subsequent episodes and update show notes or descriptions for previous episodes containing inaccuracies.
As your podcast grows, you'll face decisions about how to evolve and improve your content. Strategic development can help you maintain momentum and continue building your audience while avoiding creator burnout.
Many successful podcasts begin as solo projects but eventually expand to include additional team members who bring specialized skills and fresh perspectives. Building a team can improve quality while making the workload more manageable.
Consider adding these roles as your podcast grows:
You might start by outsourcing specific tasks through freelance platforms before making permanent hires. As your revenue grows, reinvesting in production quality and team expansion can create a virtuous cycle of improvement and growth.
When bringing on team members, look for people who share your commitment to ethical true crime coverage while bringing complementary skills or knowledge. Clear communication about expectations and responsibilities helps ensure smooth collaboration.
Expanding beyond audio allows you to reach new audiences and provide additional value to existing listeners. Cross-platform content can drive discovery while creating multiple revenue streams.
Consider these extensions of your podcast brand:
When developing cross-platform content, maintain consistency in your branding and voice while adapting to the strengths of each platform. For example, visual platforms like Instagram work well for sharing evidence photos or case timelines, while Twitter enables real-time engagement with true crime communities[4].
Remember that each platform requires dedicated attention and strategy. Rather than spreading yourself too thin, focus on one or two additional platforms initially and expand as your resources allow. Quality always trumps quantity when building your brand across platforms.
As your podcast matures, strategically evolving your content helps maintain listener interest while attracting new audiences. This evolution should be thoughtful rather than reactive to passing trends.
Consider conducting listener surveys to understand what aspects of your show resonate most strongly. This feedback can guide decisions about future episodes and format adjustments. Pay attention to which episodes generate the most downloads, social media engagement, or listener messages.
Experiment with special episodes or limited series that explore different approaches while remaining true to your core brand. These might include live recordings, collaborative episodes with other podcasters, or deep dives into specific aspects of criminal investigation that particularly interest you.
As you build relationships with experts and sources, leverage these connections to access more exclusive information or unique perspectives. These relationships can help differentiate your podcast from competitors covering similar cases.
Stay informed about developments in cases you've covered and provide updates when significant news breaks. This ongoing coverage demonstrates your commitment to the stories you tell and provides value to listeners invested in these cases.
Starting a true crime podcast represents an opportunity to contribute meaningfully to an engaging genre while potentially building a sustainable creative business. By approaching this endeavor with respect for victims, commitment to accuracy, and dedication to quality storytelling, you can create content that resonates with listeners while maintaining ethical standards.
The most successful true crime podcasts blend factual reporting with compelling storytelling, creating narratives that capture listeners' imaginations while providing accurate information[5]. This balance requires ongoing attention to both the technical aspects of production and the human elements of the stories you tell.
Remember that building an audience takes time and consistency. Focus on creating the best content you can with the resources available to you, and gradually invest in improvements as your podcast grows. Engage authentically with your listeners across platforms, building a community around shared interest in the cases you cover.
As your podcast evolves, continue educating yourself about best practices in both podcasting and true crime reporting. The landscape is constantly changing, with new platforms, technologies, and ethical considerations emerging regularly. Staying informed helps you adapt effectively while maintaining your podcast's core identity.
Whether your true crime podcast becomes a major success or remains a passionate side project, approach it with integrity and purpose. By doing so, you contribute positively to a genre that, at its best, helps us understand complex human stories while honoring the experiences of those affected by crime.
